COTTAGE CEMETERY
Main St Cottage RD
South Dayton, NY

from Betty Shellenbarger & Myrna Moss March 8, 2000.

Submitted by Carol Barber

ADELL, Elva. Born 1854, died 1932 Row 27 Sec. B Lot 26
ALDEN, Belle (Whiting). Spouse of David S. Born 1860, died 5-21-1904. Age: 43 Row 14 Sec. B lot 79
ALDEN, David S.Jr. Born 12-11-1896, died 9-21-1898. Age: 2y - Son of David S. & M. Belle (Whiting) Alden Row 14 Sec. B lot 79
ALDEN, David S. Sr. Spouse of #1 Delana E. Hubbard, #2 Belle Whiting. Born 9-11-1843, died 12-8-1902. Age: 59 - Son of Israel & Mary Ann (Hooker) Alden. Wed Delana1-1-1863. Wed Belle 1-1-1895 Row 14 Sec. B lot 79
ALDEN, Delana E. (Hubbard). Spouse of David S. Sr. Born 4-29-1845, died 10-6-1891 - Dau of Lucius & Harriet (Bunce) Hubbard Row 14 Sec. B lot 79
ALDEN, Elizabeth. Born 1900, died 12-16-1964. Age: 64 Row 14 Sec. B lot 78
ALDEN, Frank H. Born 1855, died 1929 Row 15 Sec. B lot 77
ALDEN, Isreal H. Spouse of Mary Ann. Born 4-1-1818, died 6-15-1883 Row 15 Sec. B lot 77
ALDEN, Mary Ann (Hooker). Spouse of Isreal H. Born 4-15-1820, died 7-1-1887 Row 15 Sec. B lot 77
BENTLEY, Annabell (Lowis). Spouse of Floyd Clarence. Born 3-22-1901, died 4-6-1970 - Dau of Salkeld & Sarah Ann (Hope) Lowis Row 25 Sec. C lot 86
BENTLEY, Floyd Clarence. Spouse of Annabelle Lowis. Born 8-13-1901, died 4-5-1989 - Son of Henry B. & Ida May (Peck) Bentley Row 25 Sec. C lot 86
BENTLEY, Henry Burt. Spouse of Ida. Born 4-6-1874, died 12-25-1960 - Son of Lieberant & Mary (Gullen) Bentley Row 24 Sec. C lot 87
BENTLEY, Ida May (Peck). Born 7-6-1880, died 12-11-1955 - Dau of Hiram & Laura (Stelley) Peck Row 24 Sec. C lot 87
BENTLEY, Laura P. Born 5-11-1906, died 12-22-1906 - Dau of Henry & Ida May (Peck) Bentley Row 26 Sec. B lot 30
BENTLEY, Mina (LeBarron). Spouse of Thomas L., died 5-13-1880. Age: 27 - Dau of Linus Sr. & Lizzy (Coon) LeBarron Row 15 Sec A
BLAIR, Charles W. Spouse of Pasorette. Born 1822, died 1897 - FATHER Row 6 Sec A
BLAIR, Emmet W. Born 1849, died 1904 Row 6 Sec A
BLAIR, Hattie. Born 1855, died 1922 Row 6 Sec A
BLAIR, Pasorette (Smith). Spouse of Charles W. Born 1826, died 1897 - Dau of Wm. D. & Betsy (Webb) Smith. MOTHER Row 6 Sec A
BLODGETT, Frank M. Born 1843, died 1911 Row 10 Sec A
BLODGETT, Lucy A. Spouse of #1 Franklin, #2 Martin R. Blodgett. Born 1808, died 1900 - Small broken stone.. possibly a Muzzy? 3 row 20
BLODGETT, Martin R. Spouse of #1 Polly Williams, #1 Lucy A. Born 4-23-1804, died 7-27-1871
BLODGETT, Polly (Williams). Spouse of Martin R. Born 5-30-1809, died 6-8-1838 - First wife of Martin.
BUNCE, Nelson, died 2-24-1917
COON, Aaron. Spouse of Amelia. Born 1831, died 1907 - Father Row 5 Sec A
COON, Amelia. Spouse of Aaron. Born 1831, died 1905 - Mother Row 5 Sec A
COON, Bert E. Born 1857, died 1937 Row 22 Sec B lot 149
COON, Dee. Born 1863, died 4-11-1879. Age: 16 - Son of Aaron and Pamelia Coon Row 5 Sec A
COON, Edith. Born 1870, died 1895 Row 5 Sec A
COON, Ella. Born 1866, died 1938 Row 19 Sec B
COON, Eunice (LeBarron). Spouse of Roland. Born 1817, died 1901 - Dau of Jemina LeBarron Row 14 Sec A
COON, Florence A. Born 1849, died 1907 Row 22 Sec B lot 149
COON, Frank. Born 1861, died 1915 Row 19 Sec B
COON, Gracie May, died 3-19-1889. Age: 8m 3d - Dau of Jay and Lillian Row 24 Sec B lot 43
COON, Hannah. Spouse of Jonathan, died 1-3-1879. Age: 78 Row 15 Sec A
COON, Henry. Born 1867, died 2-2-1867 - Son of Aaron and Amelia Coon Row 5 Sec A
COON, Hopy, died 12-28-1849. Age: 16y 10m 4d - Son of Jonathan and Hannah Row 15 Sec A
COON, Jacob, died 1-24-1850. Age: 28y 11m 16d - Son of Jonathan and Hannah Row 15 Sec A
COON, Jay. Spouse of Lillian. Born 1861, died 1918 Row 24 Sec B lot 43
COON, Jonathan. Spouse of Hannah, died 10-21-1863. Age: 66 Row 15 Sec A
COON, Kitty Iva, died 3-5-1889. Age: 1y 8m 7d - Dau of Jay and Lillian Row 24 Sec B lot 43
COON, Lillian. Spouse of Jay. Born 1861, died 1943 Row 24 Sec B lot 43
COON, Lorana M, died 12-16-1853. Age: 18y 5m 23d - Dau of Jonathan and Hannah Row 15 Sec A
COON, William, died 9-11-1875. Age: 36y 3m 27d Row 11 Sec A
DAVIS, Lillian G. (Guitson). Spouse of Owen. Born 10-15-1924, died 12-22-2017. Age: 93 - "Dau of Anthony and Frances (Smigel) Guitson. Born in Droyer PA, lived in Perrysburg NY, died in Buffalo NY. Three sons,
(Spouse predeceased)"
EDGERTON Stone Row 9 near MUZZY/ BLODGETT
GOODWILL, Robert. Spouse of Sally B., died 10-7-1996
GOODWILL, Sally B. (Marble). Spouse of Robert. Born 6-30-1932, died 3-19-2008. Age: 75 - Dau of Earle & Sadie (Moss) Marble
GREEN, Chloe LeBarron. Born 1825, died 1900 - Buried 12-17-1900. Don't know if she was a LeBarron or if she was married 1st to a Lebarron later to a Green
HOLDRIDGE, Anita E. (Babcock) [Ann]. Spouse of Benjamin S. Born 3-1-1919, died 3-14-2000. Age: 81 - Dau of James & Mary (Dion) Babcock. Wed 6-13-1947 in New York City Row 30 Sec. C
HOLDRIDGE, Benjamin S. Spouse of Anita E. Born 3-30-1919, died 3-2-1985 - Son of John & Ella (Beebe) Holdridge - WW II Vet, US Army Row 30 Sec. C
HOLDRIDGE, Orvis George "Red". Spouse of Patience Smith. Born 1-11-1914 - Son of John & Ella (Beebe) Holdridge - WW II Vet, US Army Combat Engineers, Pvt. Row 30 Sec. C lot 6
HOLDRIDGE, Patience (Smith). Spouse of Orvis "Red", died 3-21-1984. Age: 66 - Dau of Frederick & Cora Mae (Yoast) Smith. Wed 8-4-1945 Row 30 Sec. C lot 6
HOWARD, Linda L (Clees). Born 8-3-1939, died 3-8-2018. Age: 78 - Dau of Arthur L & Ruth M (Linsler) Clees; Born in Gowanda NY, died in Buffalo NY; retired as Keyboard Specialist at Fredonia State College. Three children
JOHNSON, Frances (Wheeler). Spouse of Calvin S. Born 3or5-5-1884, died 7-5-1882 Row 8 Sec A
LAFFERTY, Albert A. Spouse of Ann M Leonard. Born 1824, died 10-5-1909. Age: 85 - Son of Daniel and Catherine (Snyder) Lafferty Row 20 Sec B lot 151
LAFFERTY, Ann Maria (Leonard). Spouse of Albert A. Born 6-9-1826, died 11-2-1921 - Dau of Isaac Richmond and Lucy (Manchester) Leonard Row 20 Sec B lot 151
LAFFERTY, Daniel Wiley. Spouse of Ellen Leonard. Born 3-1833, died 7-1900 - Son of Daniel and Catherine Snyder Lafferty - Civil War Vet, Co A 64th Inf, NYS Vols, Pvt Row 20or23 Lot 115
LAFFERTY, Ellen. Spouse of Daniel Wiley, died 1914 - Int 2-21-1914 no stone
LAFFERTY, Emma B. (Blodgett). Spouse of Eugene S. Born 4-1-1851, died 2-24-1937 - Dau of Martin and Lucy Wheeler Muzzy Blodgett. Wed 11-12-1872 Row 20 Sec B lot 151
LAFFERTY, Ernest. Born ?, died ? - Int: 3-2-1916 no stone
LAFFERTY, Eugene S. Spouse of Emma B. Born 12-17-1850, died 1-5-1935 - Son of Albert and Anna Maria (Leonard) Lafferty Row 20 Sec B lot 151
LAFFERTY, Horace R. Born 1851, died 6-22-1907. Age: 56 - Son of Eliphas M. Lafferty and Emily (Lafferty) LeBarron. iinjuries from R. R. Accident - Civil War Vet Row 24 Sec B. lot 147
LAMB, Lydia (LeBarron). Spouse of Boughton, died 10-12-1875. Age: 70y 1m 22d - Dau of Alden and Jemina (Coon) LeBarron Row 12 Sec A
LEBARRON, Aaron. Born 1850, died 2-10-1913. Age: 60 - Son of Alamanson and Electa LeBarron. Born in Ellington, NY
LEBARRON, Alamanson. Spouse of Electra
LEBARRON, Alden. Spouse of Jemina Coon. Born 6-2-1775, died 9-28-1850. Age: 75y 3m 26d - Note: Row 13 has Alden LeBarron also. Maybe Jr? Row 14 sec A
LEBARRON, Alden ( Jr?). Spouse of Sally - Son of Alden and Jemina (Coon) LeBarron. Broken stone b. 1814?
LEBARRON, C. G. ( maybe "Gid") - Small stone, no dates or name. Poss. a child of Alden and Jemina? an old cemetery book shows 4/4/1910 rec'd of E. S. Lafferty for digging grave of Gid LeBarron
LEBARRON, E. S. - Small stone, no dates or name. Poss. a child of Alden and Jemina?
LEBARRON, Electa. Spouse of Alamanson. Born 1824, died 1875
LEBARRON, Emily (Lafferty). Spouse of #1 Eliphas Lafferty, #2 John H. LeBarron. Born 1833 - Dau Daniel and Catherine (Snyder) Lafferty. Wed in 1898. Interred 8-12-1915
LEBARRON, Emma. Born 1851, died 1857
LEBARRON, Hattie. Spouse of John H, died 5-13-1880. Age: 27 - Nee Coon? Row 15 Sec A
LEBARRON, Hiram. Born ?, died ? - Civil War Vet, Co A 90th Inf NYS Vols, Pvt.
LEBARRON, James, died 11-9-1865. Age: 18y 1m 16d - Son of Linus and Lizzie LeBarron
LEBARRON, Jemina Coon. Spouse of Alden. Born 1779, died ? - Broken stone - can' t read
LEBARRON, John H. Spouse of #1 Hattie, #2 Emily. Born 1845, died 1916 - Civil War Vet, Co A 90th Inf NYS Vols, Pvt.
LEBARRON, Julydia. Born 2-1-1852, died 2-2-1852 - Dau of Alden and Sally LeBarron
LEBARRON, L.C.B. Born ?, died ? - Poss. child of Alamanson and Electa LeBarron, Small stone
LEBARRON, Linus. Spouse of Lizzie, died 3-19-1882. Age: 81y 11m 24d
LEBARRON, Linus Jr. Born 1833, died 1922 - Poss. son of Linus and Lizzie. Int: 2-20-1922
LEBARRON, Lizzie. Spouse of Linus. Born 1805, died 1885
LEBARRON, Lois R. Born 1831, died 1895
LEBARRON, Myrtle. Born 1867, died 1878 - Dau of Alamanson and Electa LeBarron?
LEBARRON, Sally. Spouse of Alden Jr - No stone
LEBARRON, Seneca. Born 1827, died 1874
LEONARD, Isaac R. Spouse of Lucy A, died 2-6-1861. Age: 69y 1m 27d - Uncategorized Vet Row 17 Sec A
LEONARD, Joseph N. Spouse of Maryette Edgerton. Born 1820, died 1910 Row 19 Sec B lot 152
LEONARD, Lucy A. Spouse of Isaac R., died 10-5?-1853. Age: 36Y? 1m 7d Row 17 Sec A
LEONARD, Maryette (Edgerton). Spouse of Joseph N. Born 1830, died 1905 Row 19 Sec B lot 152
LEONARD, Maryette R., died 10-21-1849. Age: 18y 7m 1d - Dau of Isaac R. and Lucy A. Leonard Row 17 Sec A
LEONARD, Schulyer B., died 10-17-1849. Age: 20y 11m 2d - Son of Isaac R. and Lucy A. Leonard Row 17 Sec A
MATTESON, Royce E. Spouse of Jeanne Matteson. Born 8-10-1937, died 7-10-2022. Age: 84 - Son of Kenneth and Marian ( Brown) Matteson; born in Cottage, NY, died in South Dayton, NY; worked @ Town of Dayton Highway Dept
MCDONALD, Michael. Born 12-3-1955, died 9-29-2021. Age: 65 - Son of Paul and Helen ( Holland) McDonald; born in Buffalo, NY, died in Ocala, Fla. Of Perrysburg, NY; 2 children survive
MUSSELL, Margaret A. (Goodrich). Spouse of Robert J. Born 1-26-1924, died 5-14-2010. Age: 86y - Dau of Earl S. & Anna (Dolland) Goodrich. Born in Buffalo-NY Wed 12-27-1942 (Spouse d. 8-19-2001) 3 row 20'
MUZZY, Franklin. Spouse of Lucy A. Born 9-11-1797, died 10-11-1838 Row 9 Sec 1 ( 2nd 20' area from Cottage Rd)
MUZZY/BLODGETT, Aschsah. Born 7-13-1834, died 4-2-1862 Row 9 Sec 1
MUZZY/BLODGETT, Harvey P. Born 9-5-1835, died 12-14-1858 Row 9 Sec 1
MUZZY/BLODGETT, Luzen. Born 3-5-1833, died 3-1-1861
RANDALL, Henry. Born 1835, died 1898 - Civil War Vet, Co B 154th Inf NYS Vols
REDFIELD, Samuel Dr. Spouse of Nancy Fairchild. Born 9-18-1762, died 1837 - Wed 5-18-178 (spouse b. 8-3-1763 Guilford CT, d. 1-10-1845) - Revolutionary War. He served in the Conn. Troops and is said to have been a fifer
RUGG, Mandane Muzzy. Born 1837, died 1891 - Mandane Muzzy married Dr. Jonathan G. Rugg (also has a stone at West Perrysburg Cemetery)
SHELLENBARGER, John. Born 11-7-1956, died 12-14-1973. Age: 17 - Son of Richard & Betty (Smith) Shellenbarger
SHELLENBARGER, Richard D. Spouse of Betty L. Smith. Born 7-11-1931, died 9-17-2006. Age: 75 - Son of William E. and Isabelle (Wyatt) Shellenbarger. Born in Smithboro NY. Wed 7-2-1955 - Cold War Vet, US Navy
SNYDER, Clarence. Born 1896, died 1959 Row 32 Sec B.lot 13
SNYDER, Hattie. Born 1901 Row 32 Sec B.lot 13
SNYDER, Norene A. Born 8-5-1930, died 8-6-1930 Row 32 Sec B.lot 13
UNKNOWN Small stone Row 15 Sec A
UNKNOWN Small Stone Row 15 Sec A
VOLK, George J. Spouse of Lillian P, died 1-8-1-8-1999 - Wed 11-16-1940
VOLK, Lillian (Pagett). Spouse of George J. Born 8-5-1913, died 11-6-1999 - Dau of Garland and Betsy (Meyers) Pagett
WATSON, Patricia M. (Cole). Spouse of Robert E. Watson. Born 1-28-1935, died 4-19-2023. Age: 88 - Dau of Dr Allen & Lucille (Searle) Cole; Born in Gowanda, NY, died in Buffalo, NY. Three children
WINSHIP, Don B. Spouse of Mary Lou. Born 7-5-1929, died 2-25-2010 - Son of Fred G. & Veronica (Burns) Winship, b. Springville NY




If you have anything of genealogical or historical interest to add to this site, or if you are interested in becoming a member of the Painted Hills Genealogy Society, please contact us at:
Painted Hills

This page is maintained by the PHGS
Last Update December 6, 2023