SUGARTOWN CEMETERY
Great Valley, NY 
Submitted by PHGS member: Esther Frank

Updated by Linda Wilbur


ACKLEY, Dolly     died 12-14-1862 age 82   
ACKLEY, Eli            - No Dates  
BALL, Asa        died 1855     
BALL, Cora   born 1864 died 1910     
BALL, Lottie   born 1861 died 1904     
BALL, Stanley       died 1892     
BARROW, Benjamin             - Stone Broken  
BARROW, Betsey E.      died 11-12-1863 age 6y 5m 8d      
BARROW, Martha        died 10-29- 1885  age 75   
BARROW, Robert         died 10-31-1863 age 67y 11m 29d      
BARROW, William     born 7-14-1831 died 11-21-1900          
BERRY, Christine              - dau of John W. & Elizabeth Rowley Dickinson No Dates  
BERRY, P.O.       died 4-9-1888  age 72   
BOILETT, Ella M.       died 12-2- 1861   10y 9m      
BOILLET, Harry T.M.        died 4-3-1857  age 30y 11m 3d      
BOND, Joseph         died 8-10-1830  age 3y 6m      
BOND, Lucy         died 3-26- 1841  age 9    - Dau. of Deacon J. & Laura Bond  
BOWEN, Cary         died 10-23-1874  age 2y 4m 6d      - Son of Clark F. &  Olivia D. Bowen 
BOWEN, Clark F.  spouse of Olivia D.   born 1840 died 1920     
BOWEN, E.A. Dean    born 1835 died 1921     
BOWEN, Elias             
BOWEN, Lucinda        died 1-9- 1887 age 70y 3m      
BOWEN, Olivia D.   spouse of Clark F.  born 1845 died 1918     
BOWEN, Rev. I.L.    born 1833 died 1908     
BRYANT, Franklin Sheldon  spouse of Mary F.  born 11-13-1851  died 12-18-1922        - Son of Sheldon & Ruth Chamberlain Bryant d. Sawmill Run Little Valley NY  
BRYANT, Freeman  spouse of Frances Stanton born 8-6-1792 died 1-29-1860 age 67    - Son of Nathaniel III & Elizabeth Rude Bryant m. May 15 1818 in New Lebanon NY  
BRYANT, Hulda spouse of Archibald Creary born 4-3-1820 died 2-12-1866       - dau of Freeman & Frances Stanton Bryant m. Archibald Creary m. Mar.6 1846  
BRYANT, Julia Blair  spouse of Rodman  born 7-22-1809 died 10-12-1887    daughter of Orris Fraser 
BRYANT, Mary Florence  spouse of Franklin  born 10-26- 1858  died 9-16-1941       - b. Madison Co. Indiana m. April 23 1889 dau of Edward Campbell Harriet Curry Prigg  
BRYANT, Orren    born 1-8-1808 died 3-12-1877 age 69y 2m 4d     - S/o Nathaniel III & Elizabeth Rude Bryant  
BRYANT, Rodman   spouse of Julia B  born 8-2-1803 died 185?        - b.Chesterfield Mass son of Son of Nathaniel III & Elizabeth Rude Bryant  
BRYANT, Ruth spouse of Sheldon  born 10-22-1817  died 10-4-1908       - b.Ludlow Windsor Co. VT dau of Elijah and Ruth Googins Chamberlain  
BRYANT, Sheldon  spouse of Ruth B.  born 3-23-1812  died 1-2-1886       - S/o Nathaniel III & Elizabeth Rude Bryant  
BUTLER, Ephriam W.    born 3-28-1828 died 11-12-1897          
BUTLER, Lydia      born 7-25-1833 died 7-25-1917          
CALKINS, L.D.              - No Dates  
CALKINS, Malvina D.       died 12-2-1890 age 64   
CAMPBELL, J.A.      died 12-5-1871 age 56y 27d      
CAMPBELL, Permelia    born 1820 died 1905     
CARNES, Martha       died 1-23- 1893  age 54   
CARNES, S.                 - No Dates  
CARNES, Spencer     born 1840 died 1922     
CHAMBERLAIN, Ada J.         died 5-11- 1897  age 8d      
CHAMBERLAIN, Alta E.    born 1863       
CHAMBERLAIN, Frank     born 1830       
CHASE, Abigail        died 2-17-1847  age 23y 1m 14d     - Wife  
CHASE, Adelaide Walrath   spouse of Jonathan E born 10-31- 1851      died 1/20/1936      - daughter of Walter and Mary A Richards Walrath 
CHASE, Jonathan   spouse of Alelaide Eliza born 9-28-1846      died 8/18/1920      - son of Alexander and Mariette McIntosh Chase Civil War Vet Co I New York 2nd Mounted Rifles 
CHASE, Joseph    born 1824 died 1895     
CHASE, Lomas L.         died 10-1851          
CHASE, Lorenzo D.       died 11-29-1854 age 32y 6m 4d      
CHASE, Maryette     born 1834 died 1896     
CHASE, Moses    spouse of Aurilla Ellsworth born 1785 died 2-14-1849  age 63y 4m 22d       - son of Nathaniel & Naomi Kelly Chase 
CHASE, Nathaniel  spouse of Sophia C   born 1812        - son of Moses & Aurilla Ellsworth Chase came from French Mills NY  
CHASE, Nellie       died 3-19-1870 age 1m      
CHASE, Orren A.     born 7-9-1847 died 5-19-1928       - 154th Reg't NYS Vols.  
CHASE, Porter J.     born 1816 died 1-7-1853  age 36y 3m 6d       - son of Moses & Aurilla Ellsworth Chase 
CHASE, Robert      born 1791 died 5-31-1834  age 43    - son of Nathaniel & Naomi Kelly Chase 
CHASE, Sarah         died 5-26-1871  age 74y 9m    - Wife  
CHASE, Sophia  spouse of Nathaniel    died 5-10-1834 age 19y 1m 10d    - nee Colwell 2nd wife  
CHICKERING, Calvin    born 1809 died 1916?          
CHICKERING, Dr. Calvin        died 11-15-1847 age 38   
CHOLLETTE, Fidelia McIntosh    born 2-7-1819  died 11-2- 1908          
CLARK, Achsa     born 12-25- 1805 died 4-1-1855       - Wife  
CLARK, Catherine L.     born 3-8-1835 died 7-4-1870        - Wife  
CLARK, H.S.    born 12-8-1830 died 12-12- 1898      - 154th Reg't NYS Vols. 
CLARK, Hiram     born 12-17-1801 died 3-30-1885          
CLARK, Jane L.    born 1-7-1836 died 3-30-1885          
CLARK, M. Jane     born 10-19- 1835 died 11-1-1888          
CLARK, Mary A.     born 3-8-1833 died 3-20-1863      - Daughter  
CLEVELAND, Aaron     born 2-3-1821 died 2-5-1899          
CLEVELAND, Betsey E.    born 2-14-1792 died 11-6-1847       - Wife  
CLEVELAND, Branard     born 4-15-1788 died 6-5-1867          
CLEVELAND, Catherine    born 10-16-1832 died 8-14-1904          
CLEVELAND, Mary A.    born 8-12-1826 died 8-20-1847          
COCHRAN, Jane D.     born 1857 died 1874     
COXE, Mary J.     born 2-28-1826 died 4-23-1910          
COXE, Mervin                - No Dates  
CREARY, Archibald  spouse of Hulda Bryant  born 1819        - Also 4 sisters son of Dr. Augustus M.D.  
CREARY, Augustine     born 1856 died 1861     
CREARY, Augustus, M.D.    born 1787 died 1867     
CREARY, Benjamin     born 7-29-1811  died 5-4-1890          
CREARY, Benjamin     born 1789 died 1896     
CREARY, Betsy spouse of Spencer     died 9-14-1857 age 56   
CREARY, Clark S.     born 1853       
CREARY, Dr. Clark    born 1811       
CREARY, Elbert       died 12-15-1849 age 4m 20d     - Son of Archibald & Hulda Stanton Bryant Creary   
CREARY, Freeman E.     born 1857       
CREARY, H. Hale   born 1815 died 1887     
CREARY, Harmon A.     born 1817       
CREARY, Infant        died 1-19-1851          
CREARY, Lucy    born 1784 died 1861     
CREARY, Mary Golding spouse of William    died 8-21-1829  age 44   
CREARY, Nancy Campbell                      
CREARY, Prudence Hale spouse of Dr. A.  born 1784 died 1861     
CREARY, Rhoda      born 3-25-1815 died 1-19-1882       - Wife  
CREARY, Sophia    born 1822 died 1911     
CREARY, Spencer     born 1783 died 1846     
CREARY, Spencer        died 9-21-1865 age 61   
CREARY, William  spouse of Mary Golding  born 1785 died 1859     
CREARY, William     born 1712 died 1796     
CREARY, William     born 1759 died 1829     
DAVIDSON, Lucy       died 1878 age 84   
DAVIDSON, Susan      died 1823     
DAVIDSON, Thomas        died 1892 age 59   
DICKERSON, Charles F.     born 6-1851  died 56y 15d        
DICKERSON, Elizabeth  spouse of John W.             - nee Rowley  
DICKERSON, John W. spouse of Elizabeth     died 11-16-1844 age 70    - fife-major in the War of 1812  
DICKERSON, Sandstone             - No Dates  
EVANS, Mercy     born 1-1-1831 died 10-23-1897       - Wife  
EVANS, Sylvester    born 7-9-1818 died 3-8-1890          
FOLTS, Lyle    born 1922 died 1924     
FOLTS, Morris     born 1847 died 19??          
FOLTS, Nina C.     born 1846 died 1917      - Wife  
FOLTS, Vernice A.  spouse of Floyd    died 12-28-1905 age 27y 7m 16d      
FOSTER, Edward     born 5-27- 1833 died 9-9-1888          - Civil War  
FOYTS, Catherine    born 1902 died 1909     
FRANK, Jacob     born 2-2-1800 died 2-15- 1884          
FRANK, James D.   born 1832 died 1904     
FRANK, Margaret     born 2-28-1801  died 11-20-1887        - Wife  
FRANK, Sarah    born 1837 died 1878     
FULLER, Claude       died 1892      - Son of Frank & Lucy Fuller  
GARDNER, George        died 11-10-1837 age 22y 11m 4d      
GARDNER, Granville Decatur      died 1-18-1864       - Died in Belle I. Prison 154th Reg't Co.A NYS Vols.  
GARDNER, Horatio      born 1819        - 154th Reg't Co.H NYS Vols.  
GARDNER, Julia A.       died 5-13-1874  age 50y 5m 23d    - Wife  
Gardner, Orala      died 3-4-1880 age 59-10-8    
GARDNER, Orala         died 3-4-1880  age 59y 10m 8d      
GARDNER, Orrilla        died 10-13-1869 age 44    - Wife  
GARDNER, Stephen        died 8-22-1855  age 84   
HALL,  Paul   born 1807 died 7-21-1878     
HALL, Mary         died 9-1-1823 age 52    - Wife  
HALL, Ralph, Jr.       died 11-6-1825  age 58   
HARRISON, Alena C.H.    born 3-10-1851  died 10-2-1887          
HARRISON, Clarinda     born 1836        - Wife  
HARRISON, Mark    born 1832 died 1899     
HEWITT, Unknown spouse of Thomas    died 8-12-1849  age 66y 4m      
HICAR, Emma   1845                  
HOAG, Mildred     born 4-7-1873  died 5-5-1892          
JACKSON, Rev. M.A.                 - No Dates  
JOHNSON, Achsah     born 1837 died 12-11-1935          
JOHNSON, Emma C. Frank  spouse of John A.  born 1828 died 1909     
JOHNSON, John A. spouse of Emma C.  born 2- 1827  died 5-1-1911       - 154th Reg't NYS Vols.  
JOHNSON, Stephen T.    born 1829 died 1909      - 154th Reg't NYS Vols.  
JONES, Betsey A.     born 1845 died 1913     
JONES, Frederick        died 6-21-1854  age 40y 2m      
JONES, Oliver A.     born 1836 died 1909     
KEIR, Andrew     born 6-23- 1840  died 4-26-1919          
KEIR, Janet       died 2-1-1872  age 77   
KEIR, Jennie    born 8-11-1849 died 3-19-1901       - Wife  
KEIR, William         died 11-21-1879 age 68    - b. Balgonia, Scotland  
LOUNSBURY, Lillia B.  spouse of Thomas born 6-19-1859  died 2-4- 1902       - dau of Harrison H. & Sylvia Tryphena Markham Lewis Wife  
LOUNSBURY, Thomas   spouse of Lillia B.  born 8-6- 1855 died 5-11-1926           - son of John T. & Margaret Ryan Lounsbury 
MARVIN, A.C.        died 9-22-1842          
MARVIN, Elizabeth    born 11-2- 1818 died 5-29-1894       - Wife  
MARVIN, Ella M.    born 9-23-1844  died 1913     
MARVIN, Enoch        died 8-25- 1850  age 74   
MARVIN, F.A.    born 6-18-1820  died 9-24-1902          
McCOON, Ann Creary    born 1845 died 1904      - Wife  
McCOON, Rev. Newton     born 1835 died 1906     
McKAY, Adaline M.     born 1841 died 1914     
McKAY, Oscar     born 1839 died 1917      - Civil War  
McKEON, Albert I.     born 1846 died 1926     
McKEON, Helen Cole     born 1848 died 1881     
McKEON, Rev. D.W.     born 6-23-1811 died 6-4-1871       - died in Olean, NY  
MEACHAM, Birtha Van Slyke  spouse of Ernest Vernon        born or died 1880 
MEACHAM, Ernest Vernon spouse of Birtha V   born 1878 died 1905 age 37    - killed in a horse & buggy accident  
MELVIN, Antoinette         died 8-7-1865  age 40y 6m      
MELVIN, C.D.                  - No Dates  
METT, Kathleen spouse of Thomas W. d. born 8-30-1918 died 4-14-2007 age 88    - b. Franklinville NY dau of Zer & Grace Chapman Scott m. Oct 17 1936 in Lackawanna NY 
MOORE, Edgar L.    born 1859 died 3-29-1941          
MOORE, Eliza    born 6-6-1832 died 10-26-1878          
MOORE, Hattie E.    born 1859 died 1921     
MOORE, Lewis           
MOORE, Romanzo     born 12-23-1829 died 5-8-1864       - 154th Reg't NYS Vols.  
MORGAN, Harriet     born 4-17- 1812 died 6-26-1887       - Wife  
MORGAN, Hiram     born 10-1- 1852  died 1-5- 1875          
MORGAN, Hiram       died 10-25-1864  age 58y 8m 10d     
MORGAN, James         died 8-30-1871 age 31y 19d     - Civil War  
MORGAN, Phidelia        died 1-5-187?  age 22y 3m      
MYRICK, Hattie spouse of Eugene  born 12-2-1857  died 10-17-1885          
NELSON, Jane Ann spouse of George B. born 1823 died 2-23-1848 age 25   
OAKS, Edgar D.      died 11-8-1856          
OAKS, Hattie E.    born 1881 died 1912     
OAKS, Irving C.     born 1898 died 1916     
OAKS, Mary J.   spouse of Henry Chapman born 11-13-1870 died 1947      - dau of Leonard & Emily Oakes 
OAKS, Nettie     born 11-7-1863 died 2-6-1908          
OAKS, Raymond H.    born 1908 died 1924     
PERSONS, Ephriam P.     born 1807 died 1885     
PERSONS, Helen Laidlaw     born 1802 died 1879     
PHILLIPS, Juliana C.     born 1-22-1816 died 6-14- 1886          
PUTNAM, Arthur N.    spouse of Rose Olive   born 10-18-1871           died after 1942 
PUTNAM, C.P.               - No Dates  
PUTNAM, Elsie        died 7-31-1890 age 45y 9m 11d    - Wife  
PUTNAM, Grace Howard    born 1857 died 1929      - Wife  
PUTNAM, John M.     born 1863 died 1928     
PUTNAM, Joseph M. C.    born 1-5-1841 died 5-21-1930       - Co. H 154th Reg't NYS Vols.  
PUTNAM, Rose Olive   spouse of Arthur N.  born 2-26-1876             - died after 1942 dau of Thomas & Lillia B. Lewis Lounsbury 
REED, Caroline Creary spouse of Chickering  born 1810 died 1901      - Wife of Chickering Reed 
REED, Dr. Virgil     born 1814 died 1906     
REED, Frank M.         died 1849     
RIDER, Abbie        died 6-25-1892 age 30y 10m 4d      
RIDER, William Fox                 - No Dates  
ROOT, Betsey     born 3-30- 1829 died 2-28-1906          
ROOT, Noah M.    born 11-16-1820  died 8-9-1877          
SALISBURY, Elizabeth T.    born 1835 died 1895     
SCOTT, John     born 1816 died 1903      - Civil War  
SCOTT, Oliver        died 3-4-1857  age 42y 10m 4d      
SEE, Margaret Brown     born 1851 died 1924     
SHEPERD, Thomas N.     born 1839 died 5-22-1918        - 154th Reg't NYS Vols.  
SHERMAN, Helen M.     born 6-18-1854 died 8-12- 1894       - Wife  
SHERMAN, S.E.         died 8-28-1866          
SLOCUM, Theresa     born 1873 died 1922     
STILLMAN, Sally spouse of Erastus     died 4-28-1864  age 57y 6m 25d      
THOMAS, Charles    born 1828 died 1895     
THOMAS, Eunice       died 7-16-1869 age 67    - Wife  
THOMAS, Eva        died 6-30- 1876  age 33y 8m 21d      
THOMAS, Isaac       died 8-30-1867  age 74y 5m 10d      
THOMAS, Laura       died 2-12- 1846 age 21y 10m 16d      
THOMAS, Sarah    born 1841 died 1896      - Wife  
THOMAS, Shepard N.     born 1839 died 1918      - Civil War  
TORRANCE, Hugh     born 1819 died 1898      - Father  
TORRANCE, James     born 1853 died 1872      - d. of Scarlet Fever  
TORRANCE, John      born 1849 died 1872      - d. of Scarlet Fever  
TORRANCE, Rachel    born 1823 died 1906      - Mother  
VanSLYKE, Birtha    spouse of Ernest Vernon Meacham        born or died 1880 
VanSLYKE, Egbert   born 1851 died 1902     
VanSLYKE, Lora A.     born 1851        - Wife  
WALRATH, Elizabeth spouse of David    died 6-7-1873 age 87y 3m 23d      
WALRATH, Mary   spouse of  born 1828 died 1908     
WALRATH, Walter  spouse of  born 8-28-1826 died 1899      - 154th Reg't NYS Vols.  
WARKINS, Addie E.    born 1870       
WARKINS, Ira D.     born 1864 died 1910     
WEATHERLY, Charles    born 1829 died 1909     
WEATHERLY, Cornelia    born 1848 died 1908      - Wife   
WEATHERLY, Sandstone               - P.F.C.  
WHITTLESEY, John Pratt  spouse of Mary  born 1845 died 1904     
WHITTLESEY, Mary B   spouse of John Pratt born 1845 died 4-3-1900       - Dau. of Sheldon & Ruth Chamberlain Bryant  
WIDRIG, Conrad spouse of Harriet  born 1843 died 1915     
WIDRIG, Harriet Ayer spouse of Conrad  born 1847 died 1915      - Wife  
WILSON, Claude J.    born 1878 died 1917     
WILSON, Joseph G.     born 1843 died 1924     
WILSON, Juliette Harvey     born 1846 died 1907     
WIMPLE, Charles T.     born 12-14-1844 died 3-19- 1875      - Civil War  
WOODARD, Atcelia      born 1845 died 1907     
WOODARD, Robert J.    born 4-14-1843  died 2-9-1917       - Civil War 154th NYS Vols.  
WRIGHT, Franklin      died 10-7-1850  age 8y 21d    
WRIGHT, Frederick    born 1-8-1819 died 4-12-1883      
WRIGHT, Polly    born 10-20-1799 died 3-31-1873       
WRIGHT, Richard    born 10-26-1702 died 10-15-1857 age 64y11m21d     
 

NOTE:  We got a letter from Sarah Sully Houston, Texas and she is the great-great grandaughter of Polly Wright and
has her rocking chair, which is about 185 years old.  It has gone from Kingsbury (Washington County), to Humphreys,
to Nebraska, to Louisiana, to Mississippi, and now to Texas.  It has been through a tornado and two hurricanes that blew
out the windows, and a fire, and at some stage it rceived a coat of red lead-based paint.  It has rocked a dozen babies
to sleep and she treasures it.
 

Back To Cattaraugus County


If you have anything of genealogical or historical interest to add to this site, or if you are interested in becoming a member of the Painted Hills Genealogy Society, please contact me at:

Painted Hills

This page is maintained by the PHGS
 Last Update June 20, 2012

© 2002 by The Painted Hills Genealogy Society
Main | Email Us | Look-Ups | Members Family Pages
Chat and Meeting Room | Disclaimer