HORSESHOE CEMETERY
Town of Great Valley
Rt 417 Carrolton NY


Photos by John P. Bryant 2010

Updated by Dan Ward from list his uncle John E. Ward did in 1958 and 1977

PHGS member Cathy Jimerson (grammycat@comcast.net) photographed almost all the graves at three of the cemeteries on the Allegany Indian Reservation (in Steamburg NY [Hillside Haven], Kill Buck NY [Horseshoe] and Salamanca NY [Memorial Heights]).
She also photographed some of the graves at the United Missions cemetery on the Cattaraugus Indian Reservation (near Irving NY)


ABRAMS, Carol Jean. Born 3-31-1932, died 3-13-1995
ABRAMS, Cordella John. Spouse of Oliver Milton Sr. Born 1-21-1898, died 1991 - Member Seneca Nations of Indians Heron Clan
ABRAMS, Dale C. Spouse of Patricia A. Born 1936, died 1987 - Member Seneca Nations of Indians Snipe Clan
ABRAMS, Lloyd. Born 11-29-1907, died 10-7-1987 - Member Seneca Nations of Indians Turtle clan - WW II and Korea Vet, US Army
ABRAMS, Mary E Maybee Washington. Born 7-22-1877, died 2-8-1958 - Member Seneca Nations of Indians Turtle clan
ABRAMS, Oliver Milton Sr. Spouse of Cordella John. Born 11-23-1901, died 1-22-1958 - Member Seneca Nations of Indians Turtle clan
ABRAMS, Patricia A. Spouse of Dale C. Born 1937 - Member Seneca Nations of Indians Wolf clan. [their Children Donna-Deborah-Diane]
ANDRESS, Carol Wojcik. Born 12-20-1942, died 2-26-2003
ANDRESS, Fern Titus. Born 1918, died 1978
ANDRESS, John Russell [Crazy Bear]. Born 3-13-1939, died 8-31-2007 - Son of Jack & Fern Andress. Member of the Seneca Nation and Silversmith
ANDRESS, Micheal. Born 1-22-1940, died 1-21-1999
BARSS, Reva Cooper. Born 1906, died 1979 - Member Seneca Nations of Indians Heron clan [Let there always be trees]
BISHOP, Cecelia Titus. Born 1-26-1899, died 12-21-1924 - Member Seneca Nations of Indians Snipe clan
BYRD, Ellen Lee. Born 11-23-1940, died 1940 - Member Seneca Nations of Indians Turtle clan
CLARK, Carl Clifford. Spouse of Lily Cora (Shirley). Born 3-3-1920, died 4-19-2011. Age: 91 - Son of John & Sarah Stamps Clark b. Monterey TN. A Cherokee Nation descendant - WW II Vet, US Navy, Pacific
CLARK, Jacquelin A. (Thurston) [Suzie]. Born 4-14-1941, died 2-9-2010
CLARK, Lily Cora (Shirley). Spouse of Carl Clifford. Born 11-25-1921, died 7-1-2002 - Member Cherokee (Tsalagi) Nation of Indians Paint Clan.
COOPER, Edna *. Born 1904, died 1908 - Dau of Lewis Cooper & Louisa Redeye. Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
COOPER, Leo Clifton. Spouse of Marion G. Born 2-11-1909, died 11-9-1976 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan. Has HA YEN DOH NEES above his name
COOPER, Lewis. Spouse of Louisa
COOPER, Loretta *, died 10-11-1901 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
COOPER, Louisa Redeye *. Spouse of Lewis. Born 1865, died 1911 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
COOPER, Marion G. Spouse of Leo Clifton. Born 4-06-1921, died 9-07-2010. Age: 89 - Dau of John & Susan (Johler) Greenhauer, b. Buffalo-NY Beaver Clan GA NAH DEN TAH
CORNFIELD, Clarence. Born 1885, died 1919
CORNFIELD, William, died 1877
CROUSE, Ada. Born 5-5-1897, died 10-27-1920 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
CROUSE, Alonzo. Born 1-15-1894, died 3-2-1967 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
CROUSE, Charles Archer. Born 4-15-1888, died 9/15/1919 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
CROUSE, Ethel *. Born 1904, died 10/15/1904 - Dau of Ida Crouse ? Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
CROUSE, John *, died ?/?/1895 - Son of Ida Crouse ? Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
FARMER, Ida Shongo Crouse. Born 6-14-1862, died 3/24/1933 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
FARMER, levi. Born 1870, died 2-16-1955
FISH, Ella Jackson. Born 1874, died 5-15-1929 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
FRANK, Maude I Allen. Born 9-1886, died 5-1-1961 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
GORDON, Lila P. Born 1910, died 1960 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Turtle clan
GORDON, Mary E. Born 1947, died 1947 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Turtle clan
HILL, Baby Etta *. Age: 5 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Turtle clan
HILL, Edna Titus *. Age: 5 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
HILL, Elizabeth Redeye. Born 3-1876, died 6-14-1922 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
HILL, Margaret *. Born 1925, died 1925 ? - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Turtle clan
HILL, Muriel *. Born 1926, died 1946 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Turtle clan
HILL, Samson. Born 7-21-1899, died 1950 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
HILL, Walter *. Born 9-1-1906, died 1950 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
JASPER, Carrie Irene Pierce. Born 5-12-1887, died 1-9-1950 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe Clan
JEMISON, Charles. Born 1841, died 1907 - Civil War Vet, Co L 12th NYS Vols, Pvt. Enlisted 1863 at Buffalo for three years. Mustered out with company 7-19-1865 at Raleigh NC. (Carried as Jimmerson)
JIMERSON, Ackley Casey James, died 8/13/1997
JIMERSON, Judith. Spouse of Dan. Born 8-01-1947, died 4-06-2016. Age: 69y - Dau of Carl & Cora Shirley Clark, "Tesha", b. Monterey TN, d. Bradford PA, Wed in Columbus OH (he survives)
JIMERSON, Gladys John. Born 6-7-1913, died 5/14/1998 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
JIMERSON, Payson *. Born 1870, died 5-13-1907
JIMERSON, Pennell -Tiffanie Rose. Born 5-12-1982, died 6/4/1982
JIMERSON, William (Jack) *, died 1879 - Brother of Payson
JOHN, Eliza Redeye *. Spouse of Joseph John. Born 1839, died 3-30-1914 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
JOHN, Emeline L. Jimerson. Spouse of Henry. Born 1879, died 1952 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron Clan. Also on stone Cordelia Grace & Edith Belle, Heron Clan
JOHN, Gail Marie. Spouse of Stephen. Born 9-25-1956, died 6/7/2009. Age: 52 - Dau of Leo Fisher & Rita McMullen Fisher Kofod
JOHN, Henry. Spouse of Emeline L. Jimerson. Born 1871, died 1927 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe Clan. Also on stone Cordelia Grace & Edith Belle, Heron Clan
JOHN, Joseph *. Spouse of Eliza Redeye. Born 1835, died 2-19-1904
JOHN, Peter. Born 1880, died 1884 - Son of Joseph & Eliza Redeye John Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
KILLBUCK, Amos. Born 1844, died 5/22/1921 - Was known as Medicine man
KILLBUCK, Mary Jane. Born 2-27-1871, died 8/13/1927
KILLBUCK, Peter *. Born 1860, died ?/?/1875
LEWIS, Benjamin * - No dates
LEWIS, John II *. Born 1846, died ?/?/1875. Age: 27 - Died in railroad accident
LEWIS, John Jr. *. Born 1901, died ?/?/1901 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
LEWIS, John W. Born 9-14-1885
LEWIS, Joshua. Born 1896, died 3/23/1908 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
LEWIS, Lucy *. Born 1903, died ?/?/1903. Age: 6d - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
LEWIS, Mabel *. Born 1893, died ?/?/1913? - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
LEWIS, William *. Born 1885, died 1/5/1907 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
MATTHIAS, Cindy Jo Dougherty. Born 6-5-1964, died 2/19/2005
NICKERSON, Baby girl, died 2000. Age: Birth - Dau of Jason & Jacie Green Nickerson
NICKERSON, Jason James. Spouse of Jacie Green. Born 12-25-1976, died 9-18-2000. Age: 23 - Son of John & Barbara Nickerson, died in a car accident. Member Seneca Nation of Indians. [Beloved Son-Brother-Husband-Father]
PIERCE, Bert. Born 6-26-1875, died 2-18-1927 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe Clan
PIERCE, Emily *, died 11-1-1881 - Dau of Emma John & Lyman Pierce. Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
PIERCE, Emma John. Spouse of Lyman. Born 10-15-1857, died 11-27-1949 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe Clan
PIERCE, Harley. Born 1901, died 1980 - WW II Vet, US Army, Tec4
PIERCE, Harriet *, died 9-25-1892 - Twin dau of Emma John & Lyman Pierce Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
PIERCE, Harrison. Born 1841, died 2-22-1918
PIERCE, Harry *, died 8-30-1892 - Twin son of Emma John & Lyman Pierce Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
PIERCE, Irene Jimerson. Spouse of Frank. Born 9-16-1901, died 12-22-1970 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Beaver clan
PIERCE, Jesse, died 11-1-1879 - Son of Emma John & Lyman Pierce. Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
PIERCE, Larry A. Born 7-11-1951, died 11-4-1978
PIERCE, Lyman. Spouse of Irene Jimerson. Born 1843, died 1924 - Civil War Vet, Co M 24th Cav and 1st Prov Mounted Rifles NYS Vols, Pvt. Enlisted 1864 at Buffalo in the 24th Cav to serve one year. Transferred to 1st 6-7-1865. Mustered out with ompany 7-19-1865 at Clouds Mills VA
PIERCE, Lyman Franklin. Born 5-7-1936, died 7/18/1996 - Son of Frank and Irene (Jimerson) Pierce, Member Onandag Nation of Indians Beaver clan. Executive Director of Allegany Regional Development Corp. - Uncategorized Vet, US Army, Chaplain's Asst.
PIERCE, Marian. Born 9-15-1932, died 8-31-2007. Age: 74 - Dau of Frank & Irene Jimerson Pierce. Member of the Onondaga Nation of Indians the Beaver clan
PIERCE, Muriel John Mae. Spouse of Nathaniel "Nate". Born 10-21-1941, died 1/18/2008 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Wolf clan
PIERCE, Nathaniel [Nate]. Spouse of Muriel John. Born 7-16-1939, died 2-28-2007. Age: 67 - Son of Frank & Irene Jimerson Pierce m. Sept 16 1961. Member Seneca Nation of Indians Beaver clan
PIERCE, Spencer Webster. Born 5-1-1910, died 12-18-1953 - WW II Vet, US Army, 1209th SVG Comd Unit, Pfc
PLUMMER, Maxine. Born 11-5-1929, died 3-1-1930 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
REDEYE, Anna Cooper *. Born 7-2-1913, died 7-3-1914 - Dau of Lillian John & Sherman Redeye. Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
REDEYE, Bennett *. Spouse of Lucinda. Born 1849, died 8-5-1911 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
REDEYE, Charles. Born 4-18-1910, died 4-2-1935 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
REDEYE, Clifford C. Sr. Spouse of Phoebe O. Born 3-2-1918, died 7-27-1992 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan. Gah-Nya-Deh [Beloved parents & Grandparents. ]
REDEYE, DeForest *, died 7-5-1909 - Son of Lillian John & Sherman Redeye Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
REDEYE, Elizabeth Iona. Born 9-22-1917, died 3-27-1925 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
REDEYE, Evangeline *, died 4-24-1915 - Dau of Lillian John & Sherman Redeye. Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
REDEYE, Fred. Born 1877, died 1964 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Turtle clan
REDEYE, Henry *. Born 1872, died 4-20-1920 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
REDEYE, Johnny. Born 1900, died 1902
REDEYE, Lillian John. Spouse of Sherman. Born 8-15-1884, died 9-4-1962 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
REDEYE, Lucinda *. Spouse of Bennett, died ?/?/1936
REDEYE, Lucinda Jemison *. Born 1822, died 7-4-1923. Age: 98 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
REDEYE, Lucy, died 3-17-1911 - Dau of Lillian John & Sherman Redeye. Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
REDEYE, Matilda. Born 10-24-1906, died 2-19-1923 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
REDEYE, Mitchell E. Born 1895, died 1969 - Son of Henry and Grace Francis (Jimerson) Redeye. Brother of Sherman. Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
REDEYE, Nellie. Born 1902, died 1903 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
REDEYE, Phoebe O. Spouse of Clifford Sr. Born 10-17-1920, died 7-22-2004. Age: 83 - Dau of Ada Crouse b. Horseshoe-NY d. Kill Buck-NY Wed 2-17-1946 in Carrollton NY. Member Seneca Nation of Indians Huron clan
REDEYE, Ruth Frances *. Born 6-27-1921, died 10-13-1921 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
REDEYE, Sackett *. Spouse of Susan Jemison. Born 1841, died 1-19-1906 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
REDEYE, Sadie Pierce. Born 1883, died 6-13-1922 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
REDEYE, Sheldon. Born 5-11-1873, died 11-16-1940 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Turtle clan
REDEYE, Sherman *. Born 1898, died 1902 - Son of Henry and Grace Francis (Jimerson) Redeye. Brother of Mitchell. Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
REDEYE, Susan Jemison, died 1841
SEUFERT, Corinne Titus *. Born 7-20-1921, died 11-13-1973 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
SEUFERT, Faith. Spouse of Marshall George. Born 7-20-1920, died 11-13-1973
SEUFERT, Marshall George. Spouse of Faith. Born 1915, died 1988 - Burning Sky. Bear Clan - WW II Vet
SHONGO, Harry W. Born 7-30-1887, died 1-26-1942
SHONGO, Hazel Cooper Crouse *. Born 7-4-1899, died 10-27-1920 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
SHONGO, Howard. Born 1864, died 1913
SHONGO, Lucinda *. Spouse of Lyman Shongo, died 1830 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
SHONGO, Stephen *. Born 1815, died 2-15-1875
SWAN, Lucille Crouse *. Born 1918, died 1920 - Dau of Alice Crouse. Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
SYMES, Eldora B. Spouse of Francis H. Born 1913, died 1984 - [Together forever]
SYMES, Francis H. Spouse of Eldora B. Born 1908, died 1978 - [Together forever]
TALKHA, Gai. Born 11-26-1969, died 3-19-1982
TITUS, Dennis Jr. Born 6-4-1895, died 3-24-1933 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Snipe clan
TITUS, Dennis Sr. Born 1864, died 10-21-1933 - Lost a leg in a railroad accident
TITUS, George *, died 1863 - Indian name Ga Wah Wen
TITUS, George *. Born 6-22-1912, died 5-21-1927 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Turtle clan
TITUS, John. Born abt 1840 - Civil War Vet, Co H 53rd Inf and Co D 132th Inf NYS Vols, Cpl. Enlisted in the 53rd 1862 at Buffalo. Transferred to 132nd 9-10-1862. Mustered out with company 6-29-1865 at Salisbury NC
TITUS, Norma E. Spouse of Russell. Born 3-8-1922, died 9-14-2005. Age: 88 - Dau of Emmett & Helen Salisbury Larrabee, born in Sayre PA
TITUS, Raymond. Born 4-28-1903, died 10-9-1917
TITUS, Rhoda C. Spouse of Sylvester S. Born 1891, died 1979
TITUS, Russell. Spouse of Norma E., died 7-25-2000 - Wed in limestone in 1958
TITUS, Sylvester S. Spouse of Rhoda C. Born 1891, died 1978
WARRIOR, Mina Lewis *. Born 1890, died 1909 - Member Seneca Nation of Indians Heron clan
WATT, Nebraska. Born 2-2-1977, died 5-30-2005. Age: 28 - Son of Kim & Joan Hinman Watt, died in an auto accident. Grandparents James & Sandy Watt


Back To Cattaraugus County



If you have anything of genealogical or historical interest to add to this site, or if you are interested in becoming a member of the Painted Hills Genealogy Society, please contact us at:
Painted Hills

This page is maintained by the PHGS
Last Update July 17, 2016