BROOKLYN CEMETERY
Town of East Otto
Utley & Hammond Hill Rd.

Compiled by John & Mary E. Bryant 2006

Cemetery is unmarked but well cared for, it is behind a home on Utley Road, just off Hammond Hills Road
There are many stone unreadable & some are laying down or broken.


Photos by John Bryant


BEEBE, Edwin F. Spouse of Elizabeth J. Pratt. Born 10-30-1836, died 1900 - Born in New Haven CT, died in Catt Co NY. Wed 10-10-1860, two children. - Civil War Vet, Co B 9th Cav NYS Vols, Sgt. Enlisted 9-23-1861 at East Otto for three years. Mustered out 520-1862 at Baltimore MD
BEEBE, Elizabeth (Pratt). Born 1840, died 1933 - Dau of Darius Pratt. Wed 10-10-1860, two children. [His wife]
BEEBE, George H. Born 1830, died 1862 - Can't read rest of stone..off base sitting on ground
BOWEN, Levi, died 5-21-187?. Age: 35y 6m 5d - Ttree covering up stone
COX, ?, died 1-2?-1865 - Dau of William A. & Mary Cox
COX, Eli D. Spouse of Eliza S. Williams. Born 9-2-1806, died 9-20-1877 - Son of Horatio and Polly (Pratt) Cox, born in Erie Co NY, died in East Otto NY. [Husband of Eliza]
COX, Eliza S. (Williams). Spouse of Eli B. Born 2-2-1812, died 7-28-1888 - Born in Royalton VT, died in Catt Co NY. [His wife]
COX, Laura. Born 12-13-1851, died 6-8-1875 - Dau of Eli d. and Eliza S. (Williams) Cox, born and died in East Otto NY.
COX, Lyman? - Can't read stone
COX, Mary E. Spouse of William A. Born 1-27-1865, died 1-27-1865. Age: 28y 9m 29d - [Wife of William A.]
COX, Seward H. Born 12-29-1854, died 5-20-1856. Age: 1y 4m 21d - Son of Eli B or D & Eliza Cox, born and died in East Otto NY
CRANDALL, Ezra. Born 1827, died 1902
DAVIS, Walter. Born 1838, died 1913
DUNBAR, Sally S., died 2-26-1854 - Dau of Selah & Sophronia (Stocking) Dunbar
DUNBAR, Selah B. Spouse of Sophronia Stocking, died 6-28-1894. Age: 89y 9m 9d
DUNBAR, Sophronia (Stocking). Spouse of Selah B. Born 1-7-1808, died 7-8-1874. Age: 66y 6m 1d - [Wife of Selah B.]
FORD, Dennis D. Born 2-8-1850, died 3-16-1906. Age: 56y 1m 4d - Son of Alanson & Martha (Nichols )Ford d. in Aurora MO
HAMMOND, Mary E. Spouse of William. Born 1838, died 1912 - [His wife]
HAMMOND, William. Spouse of Mary E. Born 1834, died 1910
LOUK, Ellis U. Spouse of Lillias Hill. Born 10-1875, died 1938 - Two children
LOUK, Lillias (Hill). Spouse of Ellis U. Born 2-1878, died 1910 - Two children
MILLS, Bernice Irene. Spouse of Nelson E. Nickerson. Born 3-14-1889, died 11-1974 - Dau of James N. and Margaret J. (Beebe) Mills, born in Pittsburgh PA, died in Springville NY. Wed 1942 in Ossiopee NH as Nelson's second wife.
MILLS, Margaret Janet (Beebe) [Maggie]. Spouse of James N. Born 1864, died 1938 - Dau of Edwin F. and Elizabeth (Pratt) Beebe, born and died in East Otto NY. Wed 1888 and divorced by 1892, one daughter.
MOREY, Cynthia (Parker). Spouse of Daniel P. Born 4-29-1837, died 1904 - Wed 2-15-1853 in East Otto, two children. [Wife of Daniel P]
MOREY, Daniel Pratt. Spouse of Cynthia. Born 7-26-1831, died 7-15-1877 - Son of Barton and Elizabeth (Pratt) Morey, born and died in East Otto NY. Wed 2-15-1853 in East Otto, two children.
MOREY, Elizabeth (Pratt) [Betsey]. Spouse of Barton. Born 3-12-1807, died 11-4-1885 - Wed 10-13-1822 in East Otto, six children. [Wife of Barton]
NELLIGAN, Caroline Louise (Wing). Spouse of John E. Born 11-17-1856, died 7-10-1934 - Dau of Curtis Albert and Hannah (Wing) Wing, born, lived, and died in East Otto NY. Wed 12-24-1874, six children.
NELLIGAN, John E. Spouse of Caroline L. Wing. Born 1854, died 1936 - Wed 12-24-1874, six children.
O'BRIEN, Emma. Born 1846, died 1922
O'BRIEN, J. F. Born 1844, died 1882
OLIN -------, died 4-11-187? - Stone is very hard to read
ORR, Cyrus. Spouse of Eliza G. Eastman. Born 7-18-1788, died 1-11-1855. Age: 66y 5m 24d - Came to East Otto from Cortland Co NY in 1833, six children
ORR, Eliza G. (Eastman). Spouse of Cyrus. Born 1816, died 1886 - Six children
ORR, John W. Born abt 1843, died 9-18-1862 - Son of Cyrus and Eliza G. (Eastman) Orr. - Civil War Vet, Co C 64th Inf NYS Vols, Pvt. Enlisted 1861 at East Otto for three years. Killed in action 9-17-1862 at Antietam Md.
PERKINS, Laura M., died 6-8-1855. Age: 1y 25d
PRATT, Albert J. Spouse of Nellie R. Born 1865, died 1955
PRATT, Darius. Spouse of Jennet. Born 1799, died 1875 - [Mother & Father]
PRATT, Ellen Almina Wing. Spouse of Volney G. Sr. Born 2-20-1880, died 8-8-1941 - Dau of William Sylvester and Harriet (Rudd) Wing, born in East Otto NY, died in Salamanca NY. Wed 3-31-1900 at East Otto NY, five children.
PRATT, George Calvin. Born 11-1835, died 1922
PRATT, Helen Rosalia (Slocum) [Nellie]. Spouse of Albert J. Born 8-24-1868, died 1960 - Dau of Nathan J. and Emma E. (Wickham) Slocum, born in East Otto NY.
PRATT, Ira W. Born 1863, died 1882 - Son of George Calvin and Lydia Ann (Hotchkiss) Pratt
PRATT, Jennet. Spouse of Darius. Born 1801, died 1879 - [Mother & Father]
PRATT, Lydia A. (Hotchkiss). Born 1832, died 1882
PRATT, Volney George Sr. Born 10-12-1870, died 5-8-1948 - Son of George Calvin and Lydia Ann (Hotchkiss) Pratt, born in East Otto NY, died in Springville NY. Wed 3-31-1900 at East Otto NY, five children.
RUSH, Elizabeth A. (Morey). Spouse of Poltus. Born 9-12-1826, died 1910 - Dau of Barton and Betsey (Pratt) Morey, born in East Otto NY, died in Catt Co NY. Wed in East Otto abt 1846, at least two children. [Mother His wife]
RUSH, Hiram, died 3-9-1850 - No other information
RUSH, Lydia. Spouse of Jacob. Born 1794, died 9-18-18? - [Wife of] Born in VT, died in NY.
RUSH, Poltus. Spouse of Elizabeth A. Morey. Born 7-1818, died 1906 - Son of Poltus and Judith (Horton) Rush, born in VT, died in Catt Co NY. Wed in East Otto NY abt 1846, at least two children. [Father]
RUSH, Roxana. Born 1825, died 1901 - Five children in 1860 census
SLOCUM, Emma E. (Wickham). Spouse of Nathan J. Born 9-6-1840, died 1922 - Dau of James T. and Lovinia (Runnels) Wickham, born in Orleans Co NY, died in East Otto NY. Wed 9-28-1865, two children
SLOCUM, John. Spouse of Margaret Morrow. Born 1803, died 1877
SLOCUM, Nathan Jackson. Spouse of Emma E. Wickham. Born 4-13-1834, died 1921 - Son of John and Margaret (Morrow) Slocum, born in Herkimer Co NY, died in East Otto NY. Wed 9-28-1865, two children - Civil War Vet, Co C 64th Inf NYS Vols, Pvt. Enlisted 1861 at Otto for three years. Mustered out 9-22-1864
SOLCUM, Margaret (Morrow). Spouse of John. Born 1811, died 1886?
STEELE, Olive (Tefft). Spouse of Solomon. Born 1838, died 1914 - [His wife]
STEELE, Solomon. Spouse of Olive Tefft. Born 1838, died 1921
TEFFT, Martha H. Ford. Spouse of Rev. Dewey. Born 6-25-1825, died 6-21-1916 - Dau of Isaac and Zilpa Nichols ["because I live ye shall live also John 14-19]
UNKNOWN, Albert B., died 8-9-1868. Age: 30y 28d - Son of John A. can't read
UNKNOWN, Boy - Homemade stone that says [Mother's darling Boy], beside Almina Wing Pratt
UNKNOWN, Margaret - [Wife of James] may be dupe entry for Margaret Mills
UNKNOWN, Ransom S., died 5-15-1861
UNKNOWN, Truman - No other information
WHALEY, Austin A., died 10-26-1887. Age: 30 - Son of A.A. & S.E. Whaley [At rest] Stone is on ground leaning on the base
WHALEY, Samuel, died 1878 - G.A.R.
WHALEY, Samuel, died 1865?. Age: ?y 5m ?d - Son of Samuel & Mary Whaley
WICKHAM, Lovina (Runnels). Spouse of James T., died 7-3-1858 - [Wife of James]. (James buried in North Otto Cem)
WING, Catharine O. (Britenbacker). Spouse of Charles A. Born 6-2-1850, died 5-15-1908 - Died in Binghamton NY. Wed 1869, five children. Tree is engulfing the stone.
WING, Charles A. Spouse of Catharine O. Britenbacker). Born 10-29-1851, died 6-10-1935 - Son of Curtis Albert and Hannah Wing, born in East Otto NY, Machias NY. Five children.
WING, Charles Eugene. Spouse of Cora L. Davis. Born 1869, died 1950 - Son of Charles A. and Catherine (Britenbacker) Wing, died in East Otto NY.
WING, Cora L. (Davis). Spouse of Charles E. Born 1865, died 1937

Back To Cattaraugus County



If you have anything of genealogical or historical interest to add to this site, or if you are interested in becoming a member of the Painted Hills Genealogy Society, please contact us at:
Painted Hills

This page is maintained by the PHGS
Last Update August 15, 2016